On this week’s feedback replace, readers are discussing renders of a supertall skyscraper designed by UK studio Zaha Hadid Architects for the Trojena ski resort at Neom in Saudi Arabia.
Designed to face on high of a mountain overlooking a man-made lake, the crystalline skyscraper, named Discovery Tower, can be 330 metres tall.
“Elegant and monumental, this iconic tower will mix high-end retail, eating and the dream-like expertise of dwelling within the clouds,” mentioned the developer.
However not all commenters had been satisfied, with some dubbing it “horrendous” and “a fortress of solitude”.
“This ought to be a criminal offense”
“It seems horrendous in that lovely mountain background. As for those who want a skyscraper within the empty desert,” wrote A from W.
Petros commented “I’m having bother comprehending the environmental affect of constructing this factor. And I can not discover a single motive that may justify the hassle and cash to help the logistics.”
This sentiment was echoed by steve hassler, who questioned “how this can contribute to degrading the encompassing nature”. They added that “this ought to be a criminal offense”.
Nina Bond accredited of the design however did not agree that the construction ought to really be constructed. “We noticed it, and we like it…chapter closed,” they mentioned. “If we skilled it by this photograph, it is accomplished. We do not want it constructed.”
In the meantime, Paul Nathanson commented “I am unable to argue about practicality or technological virtuosity. Nevertheless, I needn’t. It is lovely. Interval.”
Do you agree? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“What a magnificence!”
Magnificence was additionally on the minds of readers discussing Fohlenweg, a home in Berlin that London studio O’Sullivan Skoufogolou Architects created utilizing the partitions of an current bungalow.
The three-storey household residence, developed on the sting of Grunewald Forest, encompasses a pale brick exterior divided by a band of limestone.
“What a magnificence!” exclaimed dacian.
Scot M agreed: “Stunning residence, lovely color palette in and out.”
Tony 365 chimed in to ask “the place is the bungalow?” earlier than writing “kidding apart, it is a great-looking constructing. The woodwork seems unbelievable. Brickwork strong.”
Nevertheless, not all readers had been completely gained over by the design.
“As an object, it’s a failure,” declared tom roberts. Though, they did acknowledge that “the inside has some moments”.
In the meantime, jb felt that “modernism obliterates the bungalow.”
What are your ideas on this Berlin bungalow extension? Be a part of the dialogue ›
“It seems as sickly candy as a bag of skittles”
One other skyscraper that bought readers speaking this week was the Shenzhen Girls and Kids’s Centre remodeled by Dutch structure studio MVRDV.
Aiming to set an instance for adaptive reuse within the metropolis, MVRDV retained the vast majority of the unique construction, accomplished in 1994 and made up of a 100-metre-tall tower.
A vibrant gridded facade was added to a skyscraper to create the lodge and centre devoted to the welfare of ladies and kids, containing a library, auditorium, kids’s theatre, remedy rooms and workers workplaces.
“Actually enjoyable mission,” commented Jacob Volanski.
Nevertheless, different readers had been not sure concerning the brilliant color palette.
Don Bronkema felt that “orange, pink and yellow battle” and recommended: “paint over and delist whoever perpetrated this chromatic crime.”
“Aka Jean Nouvel’s La Marseillaise facade however with uglier colors,” commented MRDRV.
Whereas Whateverandeveramen thought “it seems as sickly candy as a bag of skittles”.
What do you consider the multicoloured facade? Be a part of the dialogue ›
Feedback Replace
Dezeen is the world’s most commented structure and design journal, receiving hundreds of feedback every month from readers. Hold updated on the newest discussions on our feedback web page and subscribe to our weekly Debate e-newsletter, the place we function the perfect reader feedback from tales within the final seven days.
